If you go to Google and search for [fa cup] and then click on the players tab. The second player Google is currently listing is Issac Newton from 1600s and one of the most recognized and well known personalities of all time in science and beyond.

Here is a screen shot from Google:

I suspect Google is confusing Issac Newton with Eddie Newton? He scored in the 1997 FA Cup final and has been playing since the 90s. While Issac Newton may have never played soccer in his life.

Google has glitches like this all the time, but I felt this one was funny enough to highlight here.

Update:

Forum discussion at Google Web Search Help.